From a7011bc16ee2b976a34e1507c72739897d4916a4 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: candide guevara Date: Sun, 19 Nov 2023 00:38:07 +0100 Subject: [PATCH] brain dump of all podcasts related to nicomachean ethics --- .../0000-00-00-nicomachean-ethics.md | 160 ++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 160 insertions(+) create mode 100644 _posts/philosophy/0000-00-00-nicomachean-ethics.md diff --git a/_posts/philosophy/0000-00-00-nicomachean-ethics.md b/_posts/philosophy/0000-00-00-nicomachean-ethics.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1b70820 --- /dev/null +++ b/_posts/philosophy/0000-00-00-nicomachean-ethics.md @@ -0,0 +1,160 @@ +--- +title: Philo, Nicomachean ethics +date: 2023-11-18 +my_extra_options: [ graphviz ] +categories: [misc] +--- + +Boxes in blue correspond to my ideas. + +```myviz +digraph { + layout=dot + rankdir=BT + node [fontsize=11 fontname=sans shape=box] + + eudaimonia [shape=oval + width=2.2 + color=red + penwidth=2 + label="Eudaimonia +Human flourishing"] + good [width=1.4 + label="What is good?"] + induction [width=2.0 + label="Induction on the question +of what is the purpose +of any action."] + telos [width=2.0 + label="Telos +Live to fulfill your purpose"] + virtue [width=2.2 + label="Virtue +is the golden mean between +excessive behaviours"] + practice [width=1.8 + label="Practical +application of virtue +not only knowledge"] + phronesis [width=2.2 + color=red + penwidth=2 + label="Phronesis +allows to determine the +correct action for a situation"] + notfixed [width=2.2 + label="There is no set of +fixed laws to describe virtue."] + experience [width=2.0 + label="Life experience +nourishes our phronesis"] + endoxa [width=1.6 + label="Endoxa +Cultural context"] + reason [width=2.0 + label="Reason gives us +the ability to understand +what virtue is"] + cardinal [width=1.2 + label="Cardinal virtues +* Phronesis +* Courage +* Justice +* Temperance"] + joy [width=1.6 + color=red + penwidth=2 + label="Acting virtuosly +should bring joy"] + fakeit [width=1.8 + label="If you practice +virtue you will develop +an appreciation for it"] + education [width=1.8 + label="Education +brings us to appreciate +virtuous action"] + wealth [width=2.6 + label="Wealthy and healthy individuals +that are not burdened with pain +have the discretion for virtue"] + politic [width=2.5 + label="Politics +must understand eudaimonia to +allow the flourishing of all"] + civility [width=2.2 + color=blue + label="Civility +is phronesis applied to the +flourishing of social order"] + society [width=2.4 + color=blue + label="A virtuous society +enjoys more freedom because +it requres less laws"] + lifetime [width=2.4 + label="Considered over a lifetime +Only the trail our life leaves on +the world can be judged"] + carryon [width=1.8 + color=blue + label="Only joy can keep us +engaged with virtue +during a lifetime"] + categorical [width=2.5 + color=blue + label="Kant's categorical imperative +is sound theoretically but +cannot provide infinite willpower"] + selfish [width=2.2 + label="Selfish pursuit +Flourish for my sake only ?"] + friends [width=2.8 + label="Friendship +* Imperfect if for advantage/pleasure +* True if you act for the other's sake"] + equality [width=2.6 + label="True friendship +can only grown between equals +since your friend is another self"] + dialectic [width=2.6 + color=blue + penwidth=2 + label="Wisdom can only be +achieved through dialectic +the reflection of yourself in others"] + + eudaimonia -> virtue [dir=back, style=invis] + telos -> virtue [dir=back, constraint=false] + eudaimonia -> telos [dir=back] + good -> eudaimonia + induction -> good + virtue -> practice [dir=back] + virtue -> phronesis [dir=back] + virtue -> cardinal [dir=back] + cardinal -> phronesis [dir=back, constraint=false] + phronesis -> notfixed [dir=back] + phronesis -> civility [dir=back] + civility -> society [dir=back] + notfixed -> reason [dir=back] + notfixed -> experience [dir=back] + notfixed -> endoxa [dir=back] + endoxa -> experience [style=invis] + practice -> joy [dir=back] + joy -> fakeit [dir=back] + joy -> education [dir=back] + joy -> wealth [dir=back] + {wealth education} -> politic [dir=back] + society -> politic + lifetime -> eudaimonia + selfish -> eudaimonia + friends -> eudaimonia + categorical -> lifetime + carryon -> lifetime + equality -> friends + dialectic -> equality + + {rank=same eudaimonia good} +} +``` +