Raspberry pi 5 active cooler fan full speed all time

[wkg21]

Describe the bug

I updated my raspberry pi 5 eeprom to:

root@pineberry:/boot/firmware/overlays# rpi-eeprom-update -a
BOOTLOADER: up to date
CURRENT: Wed 22 Jan 00:16:51 UTC 2025 (1737505011)
LATEST: Wed 22 Jan 00:16:51 UTC 2025 (1737505011)
RELEASE: default (/usr/lib/firmware/raspberrypi/bootloader-2712/default)
Use raspi-config to change the release.

and after update fan connected to built-in 4-pin JST-SH PWM fan connector. started working on full speed despite low temperature:

vcgencmd measure_temp

temp=26.8'C

and is not obeying settings in /boot/firmware/config.txt

dtparam=fan_temp0=45000
dtparam=fan_temp0_hyst=5000
dtparam=fan_temp0_speed=75

dtparam=fan_temp1=50000
dtparam=fan_temp1_hyst=5000
dtparam=fan_temp1_speed=128

dtparam=fan_temp2=55000
dtparam=fan_temp2_hyst=9000
dtparam=fan_temp2_speed=192

dtparam=fan_temp3=60000
dtparam=fan_temp3_hyst=9000
dtparam=fan_temp3_speed=255

found solution this need to be added to config.txt

dtparam=cooling_fan=on

so behavior changed with a new firmware when you compare what is in README.

less /boot/overlays/README
cooling_fan Enables the Pi 5 cooling fan (enabled automatically by the firmware)

so looks like that not enabled automatically now.

Steps to reproduce the behaviour

1. have a fan connected to built-in 4-pin JST-SH PWM fan connector
2. update epprom to CURRENT: Wed 22 Jan 00:16:51 UTC 2025 (1737505011) I was on september 2024 before

Device (s)

Raspberry Pi 5

Bootloader configuration.

rpi-eeprom-update

BOOTLOADER: up to date
CURRENT: Wed 22 Jan 00:16:51 UTC 2025 (1737505011)
LATEST: Wed 22 Jan 00:16:51 UTC 2025 (1737505011)
RELEASE: default (/usr/lib/firmware/raspberrypi/bootloader-2712/default)
Use raspi-config to change the release.

System

cat /etc/rpi-issue

Raspberry Pi reference 2024-11-19
Generated using pi-gen, https://github.com/RPi-Distro/pi-gen, 891df1e21ed2b6099a2e6a13e26c91dea44b34d4, stage2

vcgencmd bootloader_version

2025/01/22 00:16:51
version a77530632346c8ac1d579fa3c369f9980401e821 (release)
timestamp 1737505011
update-time 1738681359
capabilities 0x0000007f

vcgencmd version

2025/01/22 00:16:51
Copyright (c) 2012 Broadcom
version a7753063 (release) (embedded)

uname -a

Linux pineberry 6.6.74+rpt-rpi-2712 #1 SMP PREEMPT Debian 1:6.6.74-1+rpt1 (2025-01-27) aarch64 GNU/Linux

Bootloader logs

No response

USB boot

No response

NVMe boot

No response

Network (TFTP boot)

No response

[pelwell]

Using that EEPROMversion the cooling fan is working as expected for me, with or without your dtparams, and without explicitly loading the cooling-fan overlay.

1. Where are you reading the temperature? I recommend cat /sys/class/hwmon/hwmon0/temp1_input.
2. If I unplug the fan, reboot the Pi, then plug it back in again, I get the behaviour you do. Running sudo dtparam cooling_fan fixes it. I guess that works for you as well?
3. How are you booting the Pi - SD card, or something else?

During reboot, do you see the fan twitch at all before it starts running at full speed? The firmware is supposed to let the fan spin a bit so that activity on the FAN_TACH line indicates the presence of a fan. Newer versions of the EEPROM then turn off the fan until the kernel starts, whereas it used to be left on.

[wkg21]

Ad.1 i'm using "vcgencmd measure_temp" to get temperature
Ad.2 yes i unplugged fan and plugged back and issiue persisted until i added : dtparam cooling_fan and after that fan control started working.
Ad.3 using nvme

without dtparam cooling_fan when rebooting fan was at full speed, stopped for a while and again went full speed. also when powering on it was stopped at the beginning and after a while went full speed and stayed like that.

now with "dtparam cooling_fan on" fan is not running during boot and after. it only starts when cpu goes in my case over 45 degress.

i believe /boot/overlays/README should be updated:

cooling_fan Enables the Pi 5 cooling fan (enabled automatically by the firmware)

[pelwell]

When the fan is spinning, what does cat /sys/class/hwmon/*/fan1_input show?

[pelwell]

And no, the README doesn't need updating - that is how it works for me, and it is how it should also work for you.

[wkg21]

!. fan runs at full speed.

grep fan /boot/firmware/config.txt
# dtparam=cooling_fan=on

cat /sys/class/hwmon//fan1_input
cat: '/sys/class/hwmon//fan1_input': No such file or directory

2. fan runs only when temp higher than my 45 degrees

root@pineberry:~# grep cooling /boot/firmware/config.txt
dtparam=cooling_fan=on

root@pineberry:~# vcgencmd measure_temp ; cat /sys/class/hwmon/*/fan1_input
temp=37.8'C
0

running
# stress -c 24
root@pineberry:~# vcgencmd measure_temp ; cat /sys/class/hwmon/*/fan1_input
temp=45.5'C
1789

[wkg21]

And no, the README doesn't need updating - that is how it works for me, and it is how it should also work for you.

unfortunately it doesn't for me. BTW mine is fresh install with "Raspberry Pi Imager" and "Raspberry Pi OS Lite 64bit"